John Schlick, Midwest Preconstruction Director at JE Dunn Construction, answers several common questions to help owners determine whether Construction Manager at Risk, or CMAR, is the right delivery method for their project.
Choosing a project delivery method is one of the earliest and most important decisions an owner makes. It determines when the construction manager joins the team, how design and construction decisions are coordinated, and when the owner gains meaningful visibility into cost and schedule.
Construction Manager at Risk, commonly known as CMAR, brings the construction manager into the process during design. That early involvement can help owners evaluate costs, address constructability concerns, plan procurement, and make informed decisions before the design is finalized.
But CMAR isn’t the right approach for every project. We asked John Schlick, Midwest Preconstruction Director, what owners should consider before selecting it.
CMAR can be particularly valuable for projects with complex scopes, active, or occupied sites, multiple phases, significant logistical constraints, or schedules that require early procurement.
This particular model gives the construction manager an opportunity to provide cost, schedule, constructability, and procurement input while the design is still developing. That creates more time for the team to identify risks, compare options, and make adjustments before changes become more disruptive or expensive.
If the scope is straightforward and the project has few unknowns, another delivery method may meet the owner’s needs. CMAR becomes more valuable when early construction input can help the team make better decisions before the design is finalized.
Ideally, the construction manager should join while major design decisions are still flexible.
Early involvement allows the construction manager to develop estimates at key design milestones, evaluate alternative systems and materials, monitor market conditions, identify long-lead items, and provide input on site logistics and construction sequencing.
If the construction manager joins after the design is substantially complete, the team may still benefit from additional estimating and constructability expertise. However, there are typically fewer opportunities to incorporate alternatives without redesign, additional cost, or schedule impacts.
The objective is to give the owner, architect, and construction manager enough time to make informed decisions together.
CMAR creates a structured process for managing the budget, but the delivery method itself doesn’t guarantee a specific outcome.
Throughout design, the construction manager should provide iterative estimates that show how the project is tracking against the owner’s budget. Those estimates help the team understand the cost implications of design decisions and identify potential gaps before establishing a Guaranteed Maximum Price, or GMP.
A strong GMP clearly defines the scope, trade costs, general conditions, fees, allowances, contingencies, assumptions, and exclusions. This gives the owner a transparent view of what’s included and where uncertainty remains.
Once the GMP is established, the construction manager assumes significant cost responsibility for the defined scope. However, owner-directed changes, subsequent design revisions, unforeseen conditions, and other events identified in the contract may still impact the final price.
Competitive trade bidding remains an important part of CMAR delivery.
The construction manager develops bid packages, solicits proposals from qualified trade partners, reviews scope coverage, and provides the owner and architect with a clear comparison of the results. Price is an important consideration, but it shouldn’t be the only one.
The team should also evaluate a trade partner’s experience, capacity, safety performance, approach to quality, and ability to meet the project schedule. The lowest initial number doesn’t always represent the best overall value if it creates additional risk during construction.
A transparent bidding and buyout process gives the owner visibility into market pricing while allowing the team to consider the qualifications needed to execute the work successfully.
It can, but it depends on the project’s design, permitting, and procurement strategy.
CMAR allows the team to consider releasing selected work packages before the entire design is complete. Site work, structural materials, utilities, or long-lead equipment may be procured early when there’s enough information to define the scope responsibly.
This approach can help protect milestone dates, but it requires careful coordination. Releasing a package early without sufficient design information can create gaps, changes, or rework later. The owner, architect, and construction manager should understand the purpose, risks, and dependencies of each early package before moving forward.
The answers should demonstrate more than technical capability. CMAR works best when the construction manager brings transparency, clear communication, and a collaborative approach to every stage of the project.
Relevant project experience is important, but owners should also evaluate the proposed team and the construction manager’s approach to preconstruction.
Questions to consider include:
The answers should demonstrate more than technical capability. CMAR depends on transparency, timely communication, and a willingness to work through issues collaboratively.
Owners remain active participants throughout the process.
They help establish priorities, clarify operational requirements, make timely decisions, and communicate when the project’s goals or constraints change. The construction manager and architect can provide information and recommendations, but the owner ultimately determines how to balance scope, budget, schedule, quality, and long-term value.
CMAR works best when all three parties share information openly, understand how decisions will be made, and remain focused on the owner’s goals. The delivery method provides a framework for collaboration, but the people and processes behind it determine how effectively that framework is used.
Start with the project’s specific needs rather than selecting a delivery method based on familiarity alone.
Consider the complexity of the project, the maturity of the scope, the desired schedule, funding requirements, site conditions, operational constraints, and the owner’s ability to participate in an iterative design and preconstruction process.
An early preconstruction review can help determine whether CMAR provides meaningful value or whether another delivery method would be a better fit. The goal isn’t to choose CMAR for every project. It’s to select the approach that gives the team the best opportunity to manage risk, make informed decisions, and achieve the owner’s priorities.
Want to take a deeper look at when CMAR makes sense? Read our Kansas City Business Journal article for more insights on how early collaboration can improve cost visibility, manage risk, and support better project decisions.
Fill out the form to receive The Look Ahead, JE Dunn’s quarterly economic report.

John Schlick serves as Midwest Preconstruction Director for JE Dunn Construction, leading preconstruction and estimating teams for projects across the Midwest. A graduate of Kansas State University with a degree in Construction Science and Management, John has more than 22 years of construction industry experience, including 15 years with JE Dunn Construction in Kansas City.